September 28, 2014 · chromebook technical

SD card performance tuning on Chromebook

This guide assumes you're pushing your Chromebook to do interesting things, like running Ubuntu Linux and playing DotA 2 via Steam.

You want your game to load as fast as possible, right? Right.

File systems: What you need to know

When you format a storage device - like a hard disk or SD card - you choose a file system, or method of arranging data. Wikipedia has a good roundup of how they vary per OS.

Three things you need to know:

  1. A choice of file system can affect performance.
  2. A file system has characteristics like 'how rapidly will it wear out an SD card'.
  3. A given OS on a device will only understand certain file systems. For example, Windows has no idea how to read a device formatted with the Linux file system ext4.

On Windows, everything runs a Microsoft-defined format called VFAT. VFAT is the de facto format used by most devices like cameras.

On Linux, there are many more filesystems, and they're more actively developed. What's best for gaming on an SD card?

TL;DR

1. Check VFAT speed

My SD card - a SanDisk Ultra 32GB - came out of the box formatted as VFAT. Let's get a baseline measurement of read speed before we mess with anything. We can use a tool called hdparm to get an easy reading.

You'll remember from the previous post that on Chromebook, the SD card device is normally /dev/sdb1, so let's run hdparm against it.

We measure more than one data point because we are good scientists:

$ sudo apt-get install -y hdparm
$ sudo hdparm -t /dev/sdb1
/dev/sdb1:
 Timing buffered disk reads:  54 MB in  3.02 seconds =  16.89 MB/sec
 Timing buffered disk reads:  50 MB in  3.02 seconds =  16.56 MB/sec
 Timing buffered disk reads:  50 MB in  3.02 seconds =  16.54 MB/sec

It looks like my SD card with VFAT gives about 16.67 MB/s.

2. Reformat as ext4

Chromebook and Android use ext4 as their filesystem. Therefore ext4 is cool as shit, therefore that's what we're going to use. LOGIC.

You can check this by looking for /dev/sda1 - your Chromebook's internal disk - in your mount output.

Safety warning

Put your safety goggles on. If you're going to reformat a device, do it with care - if you don't pay attention you could theoretically format your Chromebook internal disk, which I don't recommend.

Re-formatting your SD is going to remove all the data on there. Just so that's clear.

Be strong, you are an internet hero.

We will need tools

We're going to use an easy GUI tool called gparted - first install it:

$ sudo apt-get install -y gparted

The tool now appears in your Applications menu under System.

If you are fancy and have custom entries in the file /etc/fstab, go ahead and comment them out now (and reboot for good measure). If you've never heard of that, don't worry.

Format it

  1. Plug in your SD if not already.
  2. We need to eject it in ChromeOS. The physical SD stays in the Chromebook! We're just removing the mount.
  3. Confirm it's not mounted: $ mount | grep sdb1 should return nothing.
  4. Fire up Applications -> System -> GParted. You'll be prompted for your root password because this is serious adult business.
  5. Admire the colourful GUI. The different partitions on your internal disk are displayed - we're not really interested though.
  6. Look for the dropdown at top-right, so we can switch to look at the SD. As we can guess by now, sda is your internal disk (DANGER, WILL ROBINSON) and sdb is your SD card. Select sdb like this: gparted selecting the device
  7. You will see a couple of entries in the table below. Click on the partition labelled /dev/sdb1. It should show roughly the right size for your SD card (29GB for my 32GB card).
  8. Finally use the menu to Partition -> Format as... -> ext4, like this (in the screenshot my partition is already ext4, ignore that): formatting as ext4

It won't take long, less than a minute.

When that's done, physically unplug your SD and re-insert it so that ChromeOS remounts. Look for it in ChromeOS explorer - you'll see it mounts with a new and exciting directory called lost&found already there.

Let's check $ mount | grep sdb1:

/dev/sdb1 on /var/host/media/removable/SD Card type ext4 (rw,nosuid,nodev,noexec,relatime,dirsync,data=ordered)

Great - it's now ext4.

Check ownership

One last step: We need to set the SD card owner.

Since we formatted the card as root, ordinary users won't have write permissions by default. A normal vfat card looks like this when plugged in:

$ ls -l /var/host/media/removable
drwxr-xr-x 8 ubuntu ubuntu 32768 Jan  1  1970 SD Card

This assumes ubuntu is your username in Linux - you own the SD card directory. Compare this to your new ext4 SD card:

$ ls -l /var/host/media/removable
drwxr-xr-x 3 root root 4096 Aug 23 16:51 SD Card

So let's fix it with a recursive chown:

$ sudo chown ubuntu:ubuntu -R SD\ Card/

... where you replace ubuntu with your Linux username.

3. Check ext4 speed

Let's see if ext4 is faster on our SD card.

$ sudo hdparm -t /dev/sdb1
 Timing buffered disk reads:  52 MB in  3.11 seconds =  16.70 MB/sec
 Timing buffered disk reads:  50 MB in  3.00 seconds =  16.66 MB/sec
 Timing buffered disk reads:  50 MB in  3.01 seconds =  16.63 MB/sec

Nope, it's basically the same, 16.67 MB/s.

4. Readahead

One easy thing to tune is the size of the read cache. This is how much memory is set aside by Linux to predict what's going to be read next from the card.

Read performance is a good optimisation target for most games, where we're loading game data much more than writing it.

By default this is set very low, and we can gain from adjusting it. What's the default setting? Let's check (I'm using blockdev as it gives clean output):

$ sudo /sbin/blockdev --getra /dev/sdb1
256

So on my Chromebook 256kB is set aside for read caching.

Let's try some different settings and check their impact using hdparm.

$ sudo /sbin/blockdev --setra 512 /dev/sdb1
$ sudo hdparm -t /dev/sdb1
 Timing buffered disk reads:  54 MB in  3.10 seconds =  17.44 MB/sec
 ...more tests...

The max you can specify is --setra 2048. I get these numbers:

256   16.66 MB/sec
512   17.44 MB/sec
768   17.70 MB/sec
1024  17.68 MB/sec
2048  17.69 MB/sec

So a 3x readahead increase to 768kB gives best results for my card.

This is a pretty simple test so nudging it a bit higher to 1024 seems a reasonable idea.

You are special

Your SD card will vary! Do this exercise yourself and find the right number for you.

Make it sticky

This setting is lost when you reboot. For running Steam on Chromebook, I use this script to help me do the mount and set the readahead at the same time - feel free to rip it off.

This is only scratching the surface of file system tuning - let me know if you have other successful tips for a blazing SD.

Get notified when I post

Comments powered by Disqus